In the aftermath of a deadly police shooting in the Four Seasons community last week, a Prince William County supervisor wants to take advantage of police reform measures passed by the Virginia General Assembly this year to appoint a police civilian oversight committee.

The new law grants localities “clear authority” to establish civilian committees to investigate and issue findings on complaints against police, as well as officer use-of-force cases, Occoquan District Supervisor Kenny Boddye said in a news release.

The legislation was among many police reform bills finalized by state lawmakers last month, prompted by the May death of George Floyd in Minneapolis and the protests that followed. The bills touch every aspect of the state’s criminal justice system, from traffic stops to prison sentences.

“A civilian review board will both increase accountability and foster additional trust between the Prince William County Police Department and the community it serves,” Boddye said.

Boddye supported civilian oversight before taking office and began discussions with community leaders about such a committee after George Floyd’s death, his office said. He had been talking with civil rights leaders and the police department before the Dec. 10 shooting death of a suicidal 79-year-old man outside his home near Dumfries.

Boddye’s directive asks the county attorney to analyze the recent law passed by state lawmakers, said Emily Guerrero, his deputy chief of staff. It also directs the county executive’s team to analyze the financial implications, as well as launch “robust public outreach to various stakeholder groups – including civil rights organizations and law enforcement – throughout the process,” Guerrero said in an email.

Although there’s no set time frame, the intent is for county staff to come back to the Board of Supervisors with options for authority level and composition of a civilian review board, with information about each level’s legal ramifications, fiscal impacts, and reception by stakeholder groups, Guerrero said.

The move comes after five police officers shot and fatally wounded Kurtis Kay Frevert, a resident of the Four Seasons community off Route 234 between Montclair and Dumfries, outside his home in the 3600 block of Secret Grove Court around 8:15 p.m. on Dec. 10.

Frevert’s wife had called police at 7:14 p.m., reporting that her husband was suicidal, making concerning statements and armed with a handgun. When officers arrived at the 55-and-older community, her husband had left the home and was on foot with the handgun, Prince William County police 1st Sgt. Jonathan Perok said.

A Fairfax County police helicopter crew located Frevert in a nearby wooded area, where he was seen walking back toward his house, Perok said. Officers then saw the husband near the front door of the home, still armed with the handgun.

During the encounter that followed, five officers discharged their department-issued firearms at Frevert, who was struck several times. It’s unclear whether Frevert pointed his gun at officers or fired it.

Little information has been made public about Frevert, who bought the house in Four Seasons with his wife in May for $400,000, according to Prince William property records.

The involved officers have been placed on routine paid leave pending investigations by the police department’s internal affairs division and the office of Prince William Commonwealth’s Attorney Amy Ashworth.

“We understand the public’s desire to know more, which is why the commonwealth’s attorney’s office has assembled a team that is moving swiftly to gather the facts and review the incident,” Ashworth’s office said in a news release. “As this is an ongoing investigation, we will provide more information when appropriate in accordance with legal ethics.”

Acting Police Chief Jarad Phelps also released a video after the shooting in which he asked for the public’s patience as criminal and administrative investigations take place.

The incident marked one of the first uses of the police department’s new “co-responder unit” to assist during calls that involve mental health crises. County supervisors approved the unit earlier this year. The team includes an emergency services clinician and a crisis-intervention certified police officer. Beyond responding to calls, the unit also follows up with residents to help connect them to community resources.

The shooting comes as Prince William has hired Peter Newsham, chief of the D.C. Metropolitan Police Department, to head the county’s police force despite controversy over his tenure with the city police department. Newsham is scheduled to begin his job in Prince William in February.

(12) comments

Lynne June

I attended a simulation at one of the military bases where we were given the opportunity to experience active shooter simulations and determine when, who, and where to shoot with our automatic rifle lasers. Events happen with lightning speed and on the fifth active shooter simulation, I misjudged the perpetrator and actually “shot” law enforcement officer. I can tell you that experience gave me a much better appreciation for the split second decisions made by law enforcement. In those moments, it was either the shooter or the rest of us. I chose the rest of us, even though I made a mistake the last time.

Brad London

Just another liberal / democrat horrible idea which directly results in increased crime. How stupid are the people who come up with these insane ideas?

John Dutko

Cops put locks on their lockers. People will lie, cheat and steal if given the opportunity. And that is why accountability is needed. Public trust in law enforcement is fraying.

Wake Up & Smell The Coffee!

Certainly this was a tragic occurrence. But the nature of what took place, is not a recurrent one. It’s worthy of an enhanced investigation & subsequent procedural changes. But having “civilian oversight” of a police force is wrong. And because it’s wrong, I’m sure it will be implemented. Oversight of something most know nothing about, is a recipe for disaster. What next, civilian oversight of the hospitals? Bottom line, let’s all stay in our own lanes.


I have no issue with accountability to those that are protected and served by LEOs. I have no issue with transparency in policing. I encourage ride alongs so citizens can see what officers deal with. I believe your predicate is that change is necessary. I’m not certain what an “enhanced” investigation would be, not how OIS require a new process or training. OIS are actually very rare in Prince William. The new chief will review and baseline all standing orders and SOPs. Thus, shootings will be a topic with his in processing. No LEO desires to ever be in an OIS.

Wayne D.

AJH. I was responding to the first response. The way IN lines is up when hitting the reply button makes no sense.


Copy that. Thanks for the reply.


The PD shouldn’t give relevance to this clown show by even acknowledging its existence if it goes through. Boddeye is just another deranged mentally ill leftist.

Robert Segall

So you would rather the police investigate themselves rather than an independent committee? And you call someone else mentally deranged?


The Commonwealths Attorney reviews every lethal use of force officer involved shooting (OIS). What would you like the citizens to do that the trained officer of the court does not already do? An OIS requires a legal determination. If you’d like a ombudsman to review the report of findings and the opinion of the CA, that would certainly give insight. Beyond that, why would like to have an untrained, non-law enforcement opinion on an OIS? The results and findings of the CA are public record and open to review. What additional accountability are you going to achieve?

Wayne D.

You do know the Commonwealth Attorney's office does there own investigation don't you? Of course you don't. The FBI can be invited in as well if the event it's felt it might be needed. Oh yeah, the new CA is a liberal so there's that.


I believe I just said that. The new CA was duly elected, yes. FBI? Only if their crime lab was doing analytics, beyond that there is no jurisdiction unless their was a Federal crime involved. I’m struggling to understand your point.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.