Copy of Page 1_ Rural Crescent Boundary.jpg

Prince William County planners appear willing to back off proposed changes to rural areas in a potential win for conservationists.

The Board of Supervisors held its first extensive work session on updates to the county’s Comprehensive Plan during its meeting Tuesday.

The Comprehensive Plan is a guiding document for county land-use policies. While not committing the Board of County Supervisors to any decisions, it declares the county’s vision for future development.

The initially proposed revisions could threaten what’s known as the “rural crescent” – roughly 117,000 acres restricted to no more than one home for every 10 acres with strict prohibitions on the expansion of public sewer lines.

The majority of the county’s rural area is designated in the existing long-range land-use map as agricultural estate. The draft documents call for replacing that designation with agricultural and forestry, which would allow up to one home per five acres rather than one home per 10 acres.

While most of Tuesday’s work session focused on supervisors’ specific changes to the plan for their districts, the main point of contention came around the rural area.

Acting Planning Director Rebecca Horner said county staff supports reverting to the existing rules because the proposal wouldn’t achieve the county’s conservation goals.

Chair Ann Wheeler, D-At-Large, did not support one house per 10 acres or one house per five acres, saying it was “exclusionary zoning.”

“You can only build McMansions on it,” she said. “The lot itself is so expensive that people tend to build larger homes on it.”

Wheeler also said the increased density, without allowing public sewer, would increase the number of wells and septic tanks in the rural area, which is worse for the environment.

The disagreements came as the board was discussing density in the Vint Hill Road area.

Supervisor Jeanine Lawson, R-Brentsville, didn’t “buy [the] premise that it’s exclusionary.” She said clustering leads to sprawl.

“I don’t think that 10-acre lots are a problem,” she said. “I’m going to keep with my commitment to keep sewer out of the Vint Hill corridor.”

Wheeler supported allowing residential clustering in the area, which allows higher density and connections to existing power lines as long as 60% of the property is conserved as open space.

She said allowing one home per five acres would only lead to large plots being subdivided into five-acre lots with less conservation, which she called “egregious.” She said denying public sewer access, “something that’s been around since Roman times,” is “not appropriate.”

“I think clustering is the opposite of sprawl,” Wheeler said. “I think 10-acre lots is actually sprawl.”

Lawson said she and Wheeler need to hold a town hall in the area to hear from residents, which Wheeler seemed to interpret as a political ploy.

“You can always turn out people to say you don’t want development out there,” Wheeler said. “It’s our hard decision to say where we want to have growth.”

Lawson said, “I just think we owe it to the community to hear what they have to say.”

Wheeler eventually said “sure” to the town hall, but the spat continued.

“I know the people you’ll turn out. I know what you’ll do,” Wheeler said. “I’ve seen the emails you’ve sent out about people turning out to fight things.”

Lawson replied, “Madam chair, please don’t go there … I think we can have a civil town hall.”

The board discussed changes in various areas and generally offered suggestions. Supervisors advocated for more focus on affordable housing and a variety of housing options.

“Right now, we’re looking at a housing market that’s unsustainable,” said Supervisor Pete Candland, R-Gainesville. “I wouldn’t be able to afford the last two homes I lived in in Prince William County today.”

Candland and Wheeler advocated for revisions throughout the plan in some commercial districts to remove residential requirements where they didn’t make sense.

“I know we want mixed-use, but sometimes that’s not practical,” Wheeler said.

Supervisors Margaret Franklin, D-Woodbridge, and Andrea Bailey, D-Potomac, called for redevelopment of shopping centers along U.S. 1 and revitalization of historic areas, such as Batestown.

Bailey also said the area around U.S. Marine Corps Base Quantico needs a hotel, conference center and a grocery store.

County officials expect to provide the board with an updated version of the plan in around six weeks.

Nolan Stout covers Prince William County. Reach him at or @TheNolanStout on Facebook and Twitter.


(2) comments

Allen Muchnick

> “I think clustering [in rural "hamlets"] is the opposite of sprawl,” Wheeler said.

> “I think 10-acre lots is actually sprawl.”

Certainly, the BOCS needs to adopt a strategic action plan to slow or stop the subdivision of Prince William's farmland into 10-acre residential lots. However, suburban-density development in the Rural Crescent that could never be served effectively by public transportation is neither "inclusionary", affordable, nor smart.

The only effective alternative to sprawl is higher-density, mixed-use development near high-capacity transit nodes, such as along the Route 1 and Sudley Road corridors and at VRE stations. The Comp Plan should identify the declining retail strips along Route 1 and Sudley Road as preferred locations for such transit-oriented redevelopment.

John Sebastian

Agree 100%. The focus should be on developing mixed-use where it makes sense from a transit standpoint. Infill development in areas which sorely need revitalization (234 Business and Rt. 1) should be the higher priorities.

Instead, Planning staff wants to use the new "Community Mixed Use" designation nearly everywhere we have undeveloped or commercial-only land (even on parcels barely a few years old), and create "Hamlets" and "Villages" out of thin air. Both are clearly ruses to add more residential wherever possible. I'm glad Candland called them out on it and even Wheeler and some other board members seemed to agree it made no sense.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.